Classic Cream of Mushroom Soup

Classic Cream of Mushroom Soup
4.5
Average: 4.5 (2 votes)
Servings: 
Serves 1-2

This tastes just like a classic cream of mushroom soup. Thick, creamy and delicious. The real version of this soup used to be my favourite when I was young. I just made this on a whim so the measurements are from memory and may not be accurate. Taste the soup as you’re making it to be sure the measurements are to your liking. I hope you enjoy.

Ingredients: 

2 cup Water
½ cup Sunflower Seeds, or more for desired consistency
¼ cup White Button Mushrooms, chopped fine
2 tablespoon Nutritional Yeast, optional
½ teaspoon Garlic
½ teaspoon Salt
1 dash Black Pepper

Preparation: 

Blend the sunflower seeds with the water until you get a nice creamy smooth mixture. Then add the garlic, salt, yeast and pepper. Blend for a long time until slightly warm. Then, add the mushrooms and blend for about 10 seconds, just to spread them around.

Note: When I created this for the first time today I made the mistake of blending the mushrooms for a while with the soup and the flavour was much more pungent and the colour of the soup was grey, as you can see from the photo. It was still good but I know it would have been better to add them in at the last minute. You will want it to be a nice creamy off-white colour.

16 comments

Blue_Eyes's picture
Blue_Eyes wrote 21 weeks 5 days ago

would almonds and oyster mushrooms work for this?

emilyjayne's picture
emilyjayne wrote 33 weeks 6 days ago
4

I made this for dinner. It was great! I altered it a little to suit my taste, and I thought to more accurately resemble the canned mushroom soup I grew up on, I jacked up the salt.

1 1/2 cup water
½ cup Sunflower Seeds
¼ cup White Button Mushrooms, chopped fine
1/4 teaspoon Nutritional Yeast
1 small garlic clove
1 Tablespoon Salt
dash Black Pepper

Blended those; added 1/4 cup chopped mushrooms on top. Dehydrating them for a few hours would be great!

Thanks!

joannabanana's picture
joannabanana wrote 49 weeks 3 days ago

I don't have any sunflower seeds, but I have all the other ingredients. right now in my pantry, i have walnuts, peanuts, pistachios, and pumpkin seeds. do you think i could use one of those as a replacement? i am set on making this in the morning.

Amuzon1's picture
Amuzon1 wrote 1 year 1 week ago

I just made this and am enjoying it now. Thanks for this really simple recipe!

bronwyn's picture
bronwyn wrote 1 year 5 weeks ago

Thanks everyone for the lovely compliments! This has now become one of my staple raw meals.

Minimality, yeast extract is not raw and neither is nutritional yeast-that is why I listed it as an optional ingredient. As far as I know, no yeast is raw.

minimality's picture
minimality wrote 1 year 5 weeks ago

Is nutritional yeast the same with the yeast extract?
If not, is yeast extract raw?

daniefon's picture
daniefon wrote 1 year 5 weeks ago

This soup was simple and delicious! I dehydrated the mushrooms a bit before I added them to the soup. It gave them a great texture. I dried them while I heated the soup in the dehydrator, it worked really well. I like it so much that I made it last night, am going to make it again tonight and will make some to take camping this weekend!!!

rawlady's picture
rawlady wrote 1 year 5 weeks ago

This is wonderful stuff. Thanks for the recipe!!

waterbaby12347's picture
waterbaby12347 wrote 1 year 5 weeks ago

How funny, I made creamy mushroom soup today but I started with 1/2 cup soaked pecans, garlic clove, half on a medium onion. a couple of shakes of cayenne pepper, 2 TB lemon juice and a pound of mushrooms, Himilan salt to taste... Sooooo Yummmmy!!!

Mon46's picture
Mon46 wrote 1 year 5 weeks ago

I just made this, but added a lot more mushrooms and added a dash of cumin. It is delicious! Thanks so much, bronwyn.

sallyj's picture
sallyj wrote 1 year 5 weeks ago

This is fantastic. Tastes just like cream of mushroom soup! Left it in my Vita-mix for a couple of minutes to warm it up - definately a favourite.

Crue's picture
Crue wrote 1 year 5 weeks ago

Délicieux :) I want to try it with a few shiitake mushrooms as well.
thanks, I love soups in the fall :)

rosehebrew's picture
rosehebrew wrote 1 year 5 weeks ago

Thanks for posting this. It seems like with winter coming on I am wanting more soups. I am going to make this tomorrow after I get home from my weekly shopping trip. Seems pretty easy on the wallet too.

omshanti wrote 1 year 5 weeks ago

uh hahahahaha thats NUT milk..hahahahahahahaha sorry im punchy tonight

omshanti wrote 1 year 5 weeks ago

num num! im gonna make it tomarrow but with nit milk for extra umph! thanks!!!1

littlemarie's picture
littlemarie wrote 1 year 6 weeks ago

That's super weird...I just had a BUNCH of left over mushroom scraps and i just thought "I'll log into gone raw and find a mushroom soup" and this recipe is at the top of the home page!lol. Too bad i don't have sunflower seeds. darn.

Please register or login to post a comment.